The Best Crib Mattresses
The crib mattress is one of the first things you will buy for your baby.
It is an essential part of a baby’s life for the first couple of years.
Babies need a lot of sleep to develop and grow properly, which means that your baby will spend a lot of time sleeping on the mattress.
Therefore, it is necessary to find the right mattress.
In general, experts recommend that babies sleep on the more firm surface, but there is more to a perfect mattress than firmness.
To help you find the best crib mattress, we created a list of top ten mattresses for your baby.
Highest Rated Crib Mattresses (by Customer Reviews)
- 1Colgate Eco Classica III Dual firmness Eco-Friendlier Crib mattress
- 2Sealy Soybean Serenity Foam-Core Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress
- 3Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Sleep Surface Crib Mattress
- 4Serta Tranquility Eco Firm Crib and Toddler Mattress
- 5Kolcraft Pure Sleep Therapeutic 150 Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress
- 6Milliard Crib Mattress
- 7My First Premium Memory Foam Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress
- 8Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress
- 9Sealy Baby Firm Rest Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress
- 10Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress
1
Colgate Eco Classica III Dual firmness Eco-Friendlier Crib mattress
This matress from Colgate consists of eco-friendly foam and plant oils.
The mattress features two different firmness, on each side of the mattress.
Therefore, you can use the firmer side for infants, and less firm for toddlers.
This mattress model Eco Classica III is Greenguard certified which means that it passes all standards for indoor use among children.
The mattress comes with an organic cover which is also waterproof.
Check the current price on Amazon >>
Pros
- Two levels of firmness
- Eco-friendly mattress
- Waterproof cover
Cons
- Can be smaller for standard cribs
Jake's TakeBefore you buy the mattress, make sure to measure your crib, so you know accurately the mattress size you need.
The organic waterproof cover is an excellent touch.
>> Click here to see pricing, ratings, and reviews on Amazon.com <<
2
Sealy Soybean Serenity Foam-Core Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress
This crib mattress from Sealy has a firm core of soybean raised in the United States.
The cover is waterproof, plastic-free and allergy-free to ensure the safe sleep of your baby.
The size is standard and it fits most of the cribs.
It comes with airflow pockets to provide air circulation and prevent grown of mold and mildew.
Check the current price on Amazon >>
Pros
- Firm soybean core
- Certified foam free of phthalates, lead, mercury, formaldehyde, PBDEs, TDCPP or TCEP flame retardants
Cons
- Rough cover
Jake's TakeThis crib mattress is durable and can keep its shape for a long time.
The rough cover won’t bother you as soon as you put some sheets on it.
>> Click here to see pricing, ratings, and reviews on Amazon.com <<
3
Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Sleep Surface Crib Mattress
The Moonlight Slumber crib mattress comes with a hypoallergenic coat.
The mattress is free of toxic chemicals and features a low VOC for low impact on indoor air.
The mattress has two sides, one is firmer, and the other is softer suitable for older babies.
Check the current price on Amazon >>
Pros
- Extra tight stitchings
- Two sides for prolonged use
- Easy to clean
Cons
- Two sizes available
Jake's TakeIf you choose to buy this mattress from Moonlight Dremer, it will last you for long.
Use the firmer side after the baby is born, and after a couple of months, switch sides for the lighter side.
>> Click here to see pricing, ratings, and reviews on Amazon.com <<
4
Serta Tranquility Eco Firm Crib and Toddler Mattress
This Serta mattress features two firmness levels for toddlers and infants use.
The toddlers’ side is made of 100% organic cotton.
The mattress comes with 35 years manufacturer’s warranty.
It has a full perimeter border wire for stability and preserving the shape.
Check the current price on Amazon >>
Pros
- Both sides can be used
- Stable and safe
- Innerspring coils for support
Cons
- The infant side is not from 100% natural cotton
Jake's TakeIf you are looking for something longlasting and affordable, make sure to include the Serta mattresses in your choice.
It is a safe mattress that fits most of the standard cribs that you can use for several years of your child’s life.
>> Click here to see pricing, ratings, and reviews on Amazon.com <<
5
Kolcraft Pure Sleep Therapeutic 150 Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress
This crib mattress from Kolcraft is an affordable option with 150 coils for firmness and support your baby’s need during the first stage of life.
Both the cover and the stitching are waterproof, to ensure there are no odors or mold and mildew.
The Kolcraft mattress is also easy to clean. Wipe it up with the wet sponge, and it will be ready for use.
It comes with certificates for indoor baby products, including the Greenguard Gold certificate.
Check the current price on Amazon >>
Pros
- Affordable price
- Firm support
- Breathable cover, yet waterproof
Cons
- Heavy mattress
- No border rods
Jake's TakeThis mattress offers excellent support for newborns to develop and grow properly.
The cover is easy to wash, and waterproof which is always something to look for in a crib mattress.
>> Click here to see pricing, ratings, and reviews on Amazon.com <<
6
Milliard Crib Mattress
This mattress from Milliard has a sturdy shape and comfortable, high-density foam suitable for newborns.
You can also use it when your baby grows up a bit because of the other side of the mattress created to have a suitable firmness for toddlers.
It has a cotton, removable and washable cover that is waterproof.
Check the current price on Amazon >>
Pros
- The removable cover can be washing in the washing machine
- Study shape
- Comfortable for newborns and toddlers
Cons
- Heavier mattress
Jake's TakeThis heavy mattress is durable and sturdy, and your baby will love it.
The cotton cover is breathable, and the waterproof barrier prevents liquids from penetrating inside the core.
>> Click here to see pricing, ratings, and reviews on Amazon.com <<
7
My First Premium Memory Foam Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress
This crib mattress comes as a plain version or with a quilted cover.
The quilted cover option is significantly more expensive.
The mattress features hypoallergenic, mite-proof, antimicrobial and free of lead and phthalates certificates.
With the square edges it can be fit for smaller cribs.
Check the current price on Amazon >>
Pros
- Free of hazardous things
- Square edges
Cons
- Suitable for use in smaller cribs
Jake's TakeIf you want to save some money, go with the plain cover mattress style.
It will work flawlessly, but only if you a smaller crib.
>> Click here to see pricing, ratings, and reviews on Amazon.com <<
8
Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress
This mattress from Sealy features a premium foam made without phthalates, lead, mercury, formaldehyde, PBDEs, TDCPP or TCEP flame retardants.
The cover is waterproof and easy to maintain.
The mattress also comes the Greenguard Gold certificate for safe indoor use.
Check the current price on Amazon >>
Pros
- Reinforced pearl-embossed cover
- Waterproof cover
- Tight stitching for leak prevention
Cons
- Only one size available
Jake's TakeIf changing sheets annoys you, check this lightweight, yet supportive mattress.
The mattress gives the right kind of support and isn’t heavy to flip or move.
>> Click here to see pricing, ratings, and reviews on Amazon.com <<
9
Sealy Baby Firm Rest Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress
This Sealy mattress features an anti-sag technology to maintain a supportive and convenient cover.
The mattress consists of 204 coils to give the firm support recommended for newborns.
It comes with the breathable, hospital-grade antibacterial cover for safe and reliable sleeping.
Check the current price on Amazon >>
Pros
- Hospital-grade waterproof level
- 204 coils for suitable support
Cons
- Design pattern may vary
Jake's TakeIf the design pattern isn’t very significant to you, this Sealy mattress could be your baby’s most loyal ally.
Its firm and waterproof, and your baby will sleep tight on it.
>> Click here to see pricing, ratings, and reviews on Amazon.com <<
10
Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress
This mattress from Safety 1st comes in two colors – white and blue.
It comes with the thermo-bounded fiber core with a high density.
The vinyl cover is water-resistant and straightforward to clean.
The mattress has a Greenguar Gold certificate so it is safe to use indoor as a baby product.
Check the current price on Amazon >>
Pros
- Affordable price
- High-density fiber core
- Vinyl cover
Cons
- 1 firmness level
Jake's TakeThis mattress has the award of America’s Most Recommended Greenguard Gold product because of the high-quality and safety.
It is a timeless baby product that can last for many family generations.
>> Click here to see pricing, ratings, and reviews on Amazon.com <<
Crib Mattresses Buying Guide
You may think that buying a crib is the primary step in becoming a parent, but you would be wrong.
The crib itself is an essential part of your child’s life, as far as the safety and comfortability go, but the mattress is a bit more significant.
Your baby will spend most of the day in the crib, and some newborns sleep up to 18 hours per day.
So, it’s a reason more to provide your baby with the most comfortable sleep and high-quality mattress that meets all standards.
Before you run to the store or click add to the cart, let’s talk about what kind of qualities you should look in a mattress.
The Size and the Shape
Even though the proper size is the most noticeable characteristic, some people still get the wrong size.
Mattresses, as well as the cribs, come in standard sizes.
Mattresses come to be compatible with the crib size, but there are always some exceptions in the crib design that can affect the mattress size.
Therefore, if you have already purchased (or your child inherited crib from an older one) crib, take a measuring tape.
Find the exact length, width, and depth of your crib. Look at the edges. Are they sharp square or rounded?
Where does the crib railing begin?
Getting a too-small mattress for a crib can be dangerous.
It can leave some free space between railing and the mattress, so your baby can get hurt.
The cribs with standard size are 28″ x 52″, and mini cribs are 24″ x 38″.
Keep that in mind and look for a mattress that is compatible with the standard cribs.
If your crib features a different style or size, make sure to double-check the compatibility.
The mattress should be slightly smaller than the crib, not more than a few inches.
The Firmness
The crib mattress should be firmer than a conventional mattress to provide stable support and prevent the mattress deviations.
If the mattress is too soft, it can lose its shape and has a higher risk of suffocation.
On the other hand, experts connect soft mattress with sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS).
There are no scientific proves, but to be sure, buy a firm mattress.
Two Mattress Types
In general, crib mattresses can come in two types: foam and innerspring.
Both are suitable for cribs, but they have differences.
Foam mattresses are lightweight and easier to lift when changing sheets.
The innerspring mattresses have the proper firmness and can maintain the shape and required stability.
The foam core in the mattresses consists of polyurethane and can weigh from seven to 13 pounds.
The average weight of the innerspring mattress is from 15 to 30 pounds.
The innerspring mattresses are maybe more popular because most of the adult Americans still sleep on an innerspring mattress.
Also, your kid cannot use the foam mattress as a trampoline, like an innerspring one.
Quality
Cheaper mattresses come with the vinyl cover that can easily tear up.
Also, check the stickings at the ends. If it seems loose, it is better to skip that mattress than to risk it to crack after a short time.
Higher-end mattresses feature thick covering, double or triple reinforced, tight stitching for ultimate water resistance, or organic cotton.
If you are not sure which mattress is more reliable, compare the weight.
The high-density foam mattresses with high-quality coverings will weigh more.
The same goes for an innerspring mattress.
If it features high-quality steel coil springs, the weight will be higher.
Price Range
Sometimes the mattresses come as overpriced.
The price range for the mattresses that have desirable characteristics is from 40$ to 200$.
Those more expensive, around 400$ feature organic cotton, natural latex, or something similar.
Nowadays, mattresses are 2in1.
Therefore, they have a firmer side suitable for the newborns and a soft side for toddlers.
They are useful and worth investing in because you can use them for a longer time.
However, those mattresses should be thicker than the regular ones, to provide suitable firmness on both sides.
The 2in1 type of mattress can be up there in price, so before you decide, think if you are going to use it.
Additional Features
The water resistance cover isn’t new when it comes to baby mattresses, but it is a highly desirable feature.
As for other innovative characteristics, pay attention to gel cooling gel, sensory coils, and core with improved airflow.
The cooling gel is on the upper side of the mattress and can absorb the baby’s movement.
The sensory coils can feel your baby movement and respond with the shape for posture improvement.
Therefore, the baby can sleep more comfortably.
The core with an improved airflow features lower risk for mold and mildew and more breathable covering and mattress material.
However, your baby can sleep tight without these exciting features, but cannot develop properly on a soft and flimsy surface.
Certified Mattress
You don’t have to become an expert in crib safety to know which one to choose for your baby.
Luckily, there are some standards that mattresses have to meet to get the certifications that vouch for their safety.
The most significant standard is GREENGUARD® GOLD.
A mattress with this certificate marks the chemical emissions for a mattress and its impact on the air quality.
Therefore, a mattress with this certificate is free of all hazardous chemicals that can contaminate the air, and so baby’s health.
Safety Measures
Experts recommend that parents should use old mattresses for newborns, because of the higher risk for toxic gases or loose surface.
If you are buying on a budget, we recommend investing money on a suitable mattress before buying a contemporary crib.
Also, never place a baby on a waterbed or adult softer bed.
The risks are higher as with the mattresses with exposed coils or foam.
For example, an exposed coil can cause the growth of the bacteria or harm your baby.
Whatever mattress you decide to buy, always check the size, the firmness, the certificate, and the covering layer.
Conclusion
Because your baby will spend lots of time in the crib, pay attention to the mattress.
Nowadays, there are so many on the market, but the choice doesn’t have to be so hard.
Know what you are looking for, the density, the size, and the covering.
You can even read reviews to find out whether the mattress does what they claim.
Avoid used mattresses as they can be health hazards invest money in new, certified crib mattress.
What's your take on Crib Mattresses? You think they're just a luxury or a must-have item? Don't hesitate to share your comment below with your opinion!
